THE HOGGATTEER REVOLUTION
  • Homeroom
  • Orientation
    • Meet the Teacher
    • Place in the World
    • Teacher File Cabinet
  • Positivity
    • Insightful Poetry
    • Inspirational Prose
    • Meaningful Quotes
    • Positive Behavior Conversations
    • Scripture Studies
  • Exploration
    • Celebrate Good Times (Come On)
    • Cerebral Cinema >
      • Hoggatt-Made Videos
      • Mood Music
      • Music Appreciation
      • Positive Behavior Conversations
    • Coursework >
      • Cultivating America
      • Focus on Science
      • Let's Communicate
      • M4+HEM4+1C5
      • Missouri, USA
      • Recess Bell
      • Scripture Studies

The War that Made America:  Montcalm's Cross

7/16/2019

0 Comments

 
Following the Battle of Carillon, in which Montcalm and his army successfully defended Fort Carillon (Ticonderoga), most would expect a celebration, but Montcalm had a different idea.  Instead of taking credit, Montcalm gave God the credit.  The event, described in Fred Anderson's The War that Made America, is known as Montcalm's Cross.  It will be reenacted when I attend the teacher institute at Fort Ticonderoga later in the summer.
When Montcalm finally grasped what had happened, the only possible explanation that came to him was that God himself had intervened to preserve His Most Christian Majesty's dominions in North America.  In late August he ordered a huge red cross to be raised on the hilltop above the abatis where Abercromby's troops had poured out their lives for nothing.  On the cross Montcalm directed that a Latin couplet of his own composition be inscribed, along with its paraphrase:
Picture
​Chretien!  Ce ne fut point Montcalm et la prudence,
     Ces arbres renversė, ce hėros, leur exploits,
Qui des Anglais confus ont brisė l'espėrance;
     C'est le bras de ton Dieu, vainqueur sur cette croix.

Christian, behold!  Not all the care that Montcalm took,
     Nor this fearsome abatis, nor all our heroes' feats
Have stunned the English here, have shattered all their hopes;
​     Instead the arm of God prevailed, the victor of this cross.
We now know this about Montcalm:  he was a man with enough courage to stick with his convictions.  That's at least the case in this situation.  Montcalm refused to take credit or apply credit to his soldiers or any barricades they constructed.  He recognized the French win to be the work of his God.  There would be no heroism to take the attention off of God.

Whether one agrees or disagrees with Montcalm's attribution to God, one must recognize conviction and humility - two traits that we could use more of in here in the 21st century.

As I continue to reflect on this reading, I will collect my thoughts on my Fort Ticonderoga page.
I am reading this volume to help me prepare for a week-long Teacher Institution at Fort Ticonderoga,
​on the east bank of Lake Champlain in upstate New York, this summer.
0 Comments

The First World War:  Bestial Fury

7/15/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
Finally there is a chapter that reads more like a narrative and not just a collection of facts and figures with the presumption of previous knowledge.  This, the latest chapter in The First World War, describes the war.  It brings the situation to light, describing the battlefield scenes that everyday soldiers witnessed.  It is much easier to follow.

For example, a Russian officer wrote:
The scene on the German side of the border was...frightening.  For miles, haystacks, and barns were burning...Like every army under the sun, we looted and destroyed, and later hated to admit it.
German Chief of Operations Max Hoffmann recorded in his diary:
There has never been such a war as this, and never be will be again - waged with such bestial fury.
Author Hew Strachan adds:
On the same day refugees arrived in Berlin with reports 'of heads being cut off, children being burned, women raped'...
We have seen the horrors of war, but the horrors of war still shock us.  They should.  In one paragraph, this kind of information stands out:
More than half of them were prisoners of war.  And that was true for the war as a whole, not just for the summer of 1915.  In a major action on the western front casualties normally divided one-third dead, one-third would and one-third captured, and averaged over the war as a whole, the proportion of prisoners of war in relation to total losses was much smaller.
And finally, a refreshingly descriptive section, partially written by an eye witness:
'We slowly creep towards the sheer cliffs of Mount Čakor, step by step on the compacted snow,' Josip Jeras wrote in his diary, 'On either side of the road refugees are resting.  Immobilized by the snow their heads are glued to their breasts.  The white snowflakes dance around them while the alpine winds whistle their songs of death.  The heads of horses and oxen which have fallen off the path protrude from the snow.'  Following narrow tracks, rising to 3,000 feet, and with the temperature dropping to -20 [degrees], the Serbs struggled through snowdrifts and across ice to reach the Adriatic.  A hundred and forty thousand got there and were taken off by Entente vessels to Corfu, and thence to Salonika.  Of an original strength of 420,000 men in September, some 94,000 had been killed or wounded in action and a further 174,000 were captured or missing.  Civilian deaths have not been calculated.

I will hear more information about WWI, as well as about the French and Indian War,
at this summer's teacher institute at Fort Ticonderoga in Upstate New York.
For more anticipation, preparation, and reflection about my involvement in Fort Ticonderoga's Teacher Institute, please refer to my Fort Ticonderoga page.
0 Comments

Fort Ticonderoga:  Bateau Experience

7/14/2019

0 Comments

 
PicturePhoto Credit: Fort Ticonderoga
One of the titles on our schedule for the teacher institute at Fort Ticonderoga is The 1758 Campaign from the Water:  Bateau Experience.  A bateau is defined as "a light flat-bottomed riverboat used in eastern and central North America".  These boats were used extensively during the French and Indian War, even to transport heavy artillery pieces.

​
I don't know what a "Bateau Experience" entails, but it would be awesome to row around in the lake for a few minutes in one of these.


For more about the bateau at Fort Ticonderoga, check out their blog post from May 2015 which reveals that rowing the bateau across Lake Champlain takes longer to get places...and it can be pretty frightening.

For more about the Fort Ticonderoga Teacher Institute, go to my page devoted to the topic.
0 Comments

One Year Ago

7/13/2019

0 Comments

 
This is where I was about a year ago.  The session I attended on George Washington's estate focused on his wartime experiences, while the video below is from this year's session on Slavery in Washington's World.  My friend and fellow Missourian, Matt Van Horn, shot and edited the video while on property as a teacher facilitator.  I see this, and it's like I was there yesterday.
​The experience is indescribable to anyone:  people cannot understand what it is like to be an honored guest, a non-tourist, a participant in the experience of George Washington's Mount Vernon, to be there in the middle of the night, to watch the sun rise over the Potomac River, to watch a bald eagle making lazy circles in the sky, to silently pray for my nation at the slave memorial, to watch fireflies at Washington's tomb, to walk to the cadence of the fife, to touch the brick and the wood of 18th century White House, and to breathe in the Virginia - all is surreal and magnificent, and I am honored to have been a part of it.

Thanks again to the Mount Vernon Ladies Association for making it all possible.
​
For more about my experience at the teacher institute, go to my George Washington and Mount Vernon page.
0 Comments

Quote:  Challenge

7/12/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
"Don't confuse motion and progress.  A rocking horse keeps moving but does not make any progress."
​(Alfred A. Montapert)
0 Comments

The War that Made America:  To Abatis and Beyond

7/11/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
I have finally arrived at the point in Fred Anderson's account of the French and Indian War where the Battle of Fort Carillon occurs.  This is the 1758 skirmish in which the English attempted to overcome Fort Carillon (called by the British, Ticonderoga); it is also the battle that will be reenacted at the fort when I arrive later this summer.  Anderson explains some of the different tactics that have evolved in the strategies and fighting methods implemented in this part of the war:
By 1758 regular infantrymen were being trained in "bush fighting" tactics, learning how to move through the woods in single file, fight in a spread-out single rank or in loose order as skirmishers, avoid bunching up when attacked, and take cover when the command "Tree all!" rang out on the march...As the campaigns of 1758 began, troops lopped the long tails off their coats to keep them from tangling in brush; discarded regimental lace; carried spar powder in cow horns to supplement the cartridges in their cartouche boxes; trimmed back the brims on their hats and wore them slouched rather than wearing it in queues.
Reading this, one may be tempted to think, as did I, it's about time!  I thought those regular commanders would never give up their battlefield "strategies" of standing in straight lines and getting shot.  Both sides still wanted to fight in a traditional manner, but they finally figured out that war is ugly, and hiding behind a tree is not such a bad idea after all.

So here's what happened.  That big fortress kept a pretty good watch on the situation, but it sits lower than Mount Defiance.  The English were mounting an attack, but it would be crucial to begin by taking artillery up the mountain and blasting the French in the fort.  That would then signal the rest of the soldiers to march through and take command of the fort.
By noon on Thursday eight regular battalions - about seven thousand men - drawn up opposite the breastwork in battle order and readied for a frontal assault.  Six thousand provincials formed the reserve.  The army's heavy siege artillery...remained parked near the landing place, four miles away...Four field guns - three six-pounders and a howitzer - were loaded on rafts and towed down the Rivière de la Chûte, to be landed near the base of Mount Defiance.  These wer to be dragged up the hill, from which they could fire down on the rear of the French lines.  The British infantry would attack when the battery opened fire.
And then things unraveled for the English.
Unfortunately for the men drawn up to make the attack, the planned cannonade never began.  The towboat crews overshot the place where they should have landed, and drifted within range of the cannon on the southwest bastion of Fort Carillon.  The fort's gunners, noticing what was afoot, fired on the British boats.
That set the stage for complete chaos for the English.  The French commander, Montcalm, had to figure out how to defend the fort.  To do so, he had many of his troops move closer to where the English attack would finally take place, forward and outside of the fort walls.  To prepare for the enemy attack, Montcalm also instructed his men to dig trenches and set up massive piles of tree limbs, all facing outward to slow down the English.  So greatly outnumbered, this would be their only chance.

​The shots fired at the cannon-bearing boats probably signaled the English foot soldiers to charge the French fortifications.
In all likelihood it was the sound of French cannon shelling the rafts that caused the British troops to advance...According to a lieutenant in the Highland..."The abatis...was what gave them the fatal advantage over us."  The entangled branches of its "monstrous large fir and oak trees...not only broke our ranks, and made it impossible to us to keep our order, but...put it entirely out of our power to advance briskly; which gave the enemy abundance of time to mow us down like a field of corn, with their wall pieces and small arms, before we fired a single shot."

...At least 551 redcoats and provincials died and more than thirteen hundred were wounded trying to come to grips with the thirty-six hundred well-protected French and Canadian troops who methodically cut them to shreds.  The Battle of Ticonderoga, as the Anglo-Americans called it, was the heaviest loss of life that His Majesty's forces sustained during the whole American war.  It was, in fact, the bloodiest day the British army would see in North America until the Battle of New Orleans in 1815.  The French, by contrast, suffered a total of 377 casualties.

​Montcalm expected that the British would renew the attack the next morning, and was surprised when they did not...[H]e waited until Saturday before sending out a reconnaissance party to see what had become of the enemy.  What they found - "wounded [men], provisions, abandoned equipment, shoes left in miry places, remains of barges and burned pontoons" - was evidence of the panic that had gripped Abercromby's defeated force...By dawn the greatest army Britain had ever assembled in North America was rowing frantically for the other end of Lake George, fleeing an enemy that it still outnumbered by more than three to one...
This vision of the British soldiers tangled in the limbs of the abatis while being picked off by the French is a fascinating one.  It's easy to imagine the pride in the French ranks.  They had just pulled off the greatest upset of the war, but with Montcalm at the helm, that pride would soon be put to the side.  I'll write more about that later.

​As I continue to reflect on this reading, I will collect my thoughts on my Fort Ticonderoga page.
I am reading this volume to help me prepare for a week-long Teacher Institution at Fort Ticonderoga,
​on the east bank of Lake Champlain in upstate New York, this summer.
0 Comments

The First World War:  The Ottoman Influence

7/10/2019

0 Comments

 
I'm going to skip around in this writing, just hitting some of the highlights that attracted my attention in the last chapter.

I don't remember much of what I'm reading in Hew Strachan's The First World War (I don't even understand much of it, not having any background in WWI history.), but some things stand out as I'm reading them.  One of those things comes in the form of a chapter headline:  Jihad.  It is a topic that makes sensational headlines in 2019, let alone a hundred years in our past.  The chapter begins with this:
Picture
In Constantinople, capital of the Ottoman Empire, the Sheikh-ul-Islam declared an Islamic holy war against Britain, France, Russian, Serbia, and Montenegro on 14 November 1914.  He spoke on behalf of the Caliphate, a combination of spiritual and temporal authority claimed by the Sultan, and justified by the fact that the holy cities of Mecca and Medina fell within the purlieus of his rule.  But the reach of the Ottoman Empire, which at its height in the sixteenth century had extended from the Persian Gulf to Poland, and from Cairo to the gates of Vienna, was contracting.  In 1914, of 270 million Muslims in the world in 1914 [sic], only about 30 million were under French rule, most of them in North and Equatorial Africa; and another 20 million were incorporated in Russia's Asian empire.  Those Muslims in the British, French and Russian empires who opposed the Ottoman Empire's summons to holy war were promised 'the fire of hell'.  The Muslims in Serbia and Montenegro, who were likely to commit the lesser offence of fighting Austria-Hungary, would merit only 'painful torment'.
While the chapter tells more about the Ottoman Empire and the "holy war", Strachan seems to focus more on the movements within the war at this point than the religious dogmas that drove this portion of the war.  The next tidbit comes from the same chapter, but demonstrates the Empire's bargaining value.  Not only does this display the desires of nations and militaries, but it better demonstrates how complicated the thought processes and strategies can be when war is concerned.
Moltke's problem was that the German army and German weapons were all fully committed to the war in Europe.  He had no rifles he could send to those who might rise against British, French or Russian rule, and certainly no troops.  And, even if he had them, British naval supremacy meant that he could not send them by sea.  The Ottoman Empire could confer two strategic benefits on Germany:  its army could provide the troops for overseas deployment and its land mass could open the overland routes to Central Asia and Africa.
At the same time, cultural differences are hardly understood.  I've recently read about the Indian practice of kidnapping/adopting members of the enemy or innocent bystanders during the French and Indian War in the 1750s, but something similar happened among the Turks.  In the case of the Indians, the desire was to maintain numbers and keep the tribal population up; in the case of the Turks, desires may have been more carnal in nature.
...The American consul in Erzurum, Leslie Davis, reported from Kharput, the principal transit point, in July that 'The Turks have already chosen the most pretty from among the children and young girls.  They will serve as slaves, if they do not serve ends that are more vile'.  He was struck by how few men he could see, and concluded that they had been killed on the road.  Many thousands of Armenians also succumbed to famine and disease.  Mortality among the 200,000 to 300,000 who fled to the comparative safety of Russia rose to perhaps 50 per cent, thanks to cholera, dysentery and typhus...
With all of the competition for allies and territory, big things were also happening in health.  Not only in the diseases from that last clip, but also in hardships produced by extreme climate and landforms.  These struggles of a new battlefield were difficult for soldiers who were not used to them.  In this, I am also reminded of the difficulties the British and the French had in understanding the terrain of the Lake George/Lake Champlain area, where they had to learn to use the terrain for strategy and advantage rather than sit back and lament their situation.
...The differences from the western front were were the products of the terrain and the climate.  The narrow and steep foothold on the shore meant that the positions had little depth, and that the only relief was to go for a swim in the sea.  But the heat that made that an attractive option also brought flies and then disease, particularly dysentery; water supplies were a constant headache.  Only 30 per cent of British casualties in the campaign were sustained in battle.
Again, these thoughts are just the ones that came to me upon the reading of the chapter.  They may be a bit disjointed in my reflection here, but they are a beginning on a journey of understanding more about WWI.  As I continue to read about two wars - the French and Indian War and World War I - I hope to build on the foundations that are beginning to form in my mind.

I am reading this book to prepare for my week-long teacher institution at Fort Ticonderoga in upstate New York,
this summer.  Follow the link to my Fort Ticonderoga page for more.
0 Comments

Fort Ticonderoga:  Historic Trades

7/9/2019

0 Comments

 
One of the activities I will enjoy at Fort Ticonderoga for this summer's teacher institute is an immersion into the historic trades of the 18th century.  Specifically listed on our itinerary are tailoring, maritime carpentry, and animal husbandry, but there is a whole lot more of these trades available for observation at the fort.  The word immersion​ implies that this will be a hands-on activity.

Here are some videos I found from a few years ago that shows some of the offerings.
0 Comments

Fort "Carry On"

7/8/2019

0 Comments

 

(LIBERTY) BELL WORK

How many candles would be
on Montcalm's cake, ​this year?


Birthday:  February 28, 1712
Picture
How many words can you make
from the letters in his name?


L O U I S - J O S E P H     D E     M O N T C A L M

Do the Math
​Find the sum of the letters of his name,
using the scale below.

​A = $.01, B = $.02, C = $.03, D = $.04, E = $.05,
F = $.06, G = $.7, H =  $.08, I = $.09, J = $.10,
K = $.11, L = $.12, M = $.13, N = $.14, O = $.15,
P = $.16, Q = $.17, R = $.18, S = $.19,
T = $.20, U = $.21, V = $.22, W = $.23,
X = $.24, Y = $.25, Z = $.26

Quick Write:  What are some things you have to "guard" yourself against?
On Target
Write the target number in the "bull's eye".
In the 20 other open sections of the target,
write equations to equal the target number.

Today's number is 8.

For example, if the target number is 36, the student may write expressions like the ones here (right):
Picture
6 squared
2 x 18
3 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 6 + 7 + 8
72/2

3 x 3 x 4

Sentence Surgery
Read the sentence below.  Do you see any problems?  Do not rewrite the sentence.  In fact, don't even fix the sentence.  Instead, on your paper, tell the writer three things that need to be corrected.

the french army builded fort carilon
Sentence Augmentation*
Augment the sentence below to greatly improve it.  Record your improved sentence on your paper.

They guarded the lake.
​
​
*Augment:  make (something) greater by adding to it

Word Work
Using words important to this lesson set,
​create a list of words to fit in the categories below.
​Pay particular attention to spelling patterns.
Fort​ (words with or)
Carillon (words with -on)
Word Wise
Define the ​following words:

carillon
​
fort

Picture

Mood Music

Allow the military marches of the French Royal Army to transport you into a scene that has yet to be written.  Draw the scene as you listen.  Then write, using all the visual imagery you can muster.

Art Appreciation I

Picture
Observe the unique painting above.
  • What do you notice?
  • What do you wonder?
  • What is happening?
  • Write your thoughts.
Picture
Picture
It must have been a frightening prospect - sitting in Britain in 1939, awaiting a German air attack.  World War II was upon the people of England, and they knew the fight would come to their home soil.

The government, in an attempt to encourage British citizenry, created and distributed the now-famous Keep Calm and Carry On posters.  During the war and the reconstruction time to follow the war, variations of the posters continued to inspire the people to persevere.

The posters have nothing to do with the French and Indian War of the 1750s, but as we introduce America's Fort, today, I thought of those posters.
Why?  Because when the French were battling the English in the Lake Champlain region of Upstate New York and Vermont, the French built a stone fortress to keep guard of the strategic lake from English troops descending Lake George.  They named it Fort Carillon (pronounced something like Carry On​) because of the sound of the water descending through the La Chute River resembling the sounds of a bell tower, or a carillon.
So why don't we have a little fun with the pronunciation and make our own positive, motivational posters.  What will yours say?  Keep _____ and Carry On.  What insignia will you place at the top instead of the Tudor Crown?
Picture
Picture

Music Appreciation

Hakuna Matata
The Fear
​Live It Up
Picture
Picture
Picture

A Star Is Born

The bastion fort, or star-shaped forts became popular in Europe in the mid 15th century.  The shape was meant to assist in the defense of the fort by allowing for the optimal use of cannon and mortar.

Fort Carillon was built at Lake Champlain for the same reason.  Another, Fort Wood, constructed on Liberty Island in New York City, was repurposed to provide the foundation for the Statue of Liberty.  Fort Wood was built to defend our young nation from British invasion in the early 1800s.
Picture
Picture

Art Appreciation II

Observe the unique painting below.
  • What do you notice?
  • What do you wonder?
  • What is happening?
  • Write your thoughts.
Picture

Outnumbered

The Battle of Carillon began on July 8, 1758, with some 16,000 British troops attacking the 4,000 French soldiers.  Louis-Joseph de Montcalm successfully defended the fort even against such unbalanced odds.  He did so partially through the use of abatis (See the video here for more clarity about the battle.).

To Abatis and Beyond

The Geometry of Defense
File Size: 32222 kb
File Type: docx
Download File

Think you could get through the abatis?  Try an activity in class to safely make your way through the obstacle. Remember, the opposing army is rooting against you, but there is no turning back.  The king of England is counting on you to take this important fortress from the French.
Picture
Picture

Montcalm's Cross

Following the Battle of Carillon, the Marquis de Montcalm raised a cross inscribed with the message and its rough English translation seen here (below). He took no credit for the victory and gave no credit to his strategy or his men. Instead, he credited his God, demonstrating that the French and Indian War was not only a war for territory, but that it was also a religious war of ideals.
Chretien!  Ce ne fut point Montcalm et la prudence,
Ces arbres renversė, ce hėros, leur exploits,
Qui des Anglais confus ont brisė l'espėrance;
C'est le bras de ton Dieu, vainqueur sur cette croix.

Christian, behold!  Not all the care than Montcalm took,
Nor this fearsome abatis, nor all our heroes' feats
Have stunned the English here, have shattered all their hopes;
​Instead the arm of God prevailed, the victor of this cross.
Picture
Picture

DIY:  CARVED POWDER HORNS

Among other historical relics from the 18th century, Fort Ticonderoga boasts a significant collection of decorated powder horns.  Used for carrying black powder on the battlefield, powder horns made it possible to go without using pre-prepared cartridges.

Soldiers carved the horns with images of the fort and other information.  Today, you can do the same.  We don't have actual horns, but we do have...bananas!
Use the template from the Museum of the American Revolution.
Picture

Where the Waters Meet

A year after the Battle of Carillon, the British were finally ready to take the fort.  The 400 Frenchmen remaining in the fort would be no match for the 11,000-man British force.  This short-lived 1759 event is called the Battle of Ticonderoga (Ticonderoga means "where the waters meet".).

As the French withdrew, they desired to make the fort as useless as possible for the English.  Before they left, the French spiked and dumped the cannons and used explosives to destroy the fort as much as possible.  The fort was still in ruins in 1777, when American soldiers would capture it from British control during the Revolution (something we will hear more about later in the school year).
Picture
Picture
Through the leadership of Stephen Pell, the fort was restored during the years between the two world wars and is now presented to visitors as a fine representation of the history of our nation.
0 Comments

Forgetting History?  Forget the Future.

7/7/2019

0 Comments

 
Someone on my Facebook feed recently posted an online article from last October, entitled "Americans Have Almost Entirely Forgotten Their History" authored by Jarrett Stepman for The Daily Signal from the Heritage Foundation.

Understandably, the Heritage Foundation leans to the right (something of a rarity these days), but I'll stick to the facts of the article and draw my own conclusions.

​The article begins:
In America, we celebrate democracy and are justifiably proud that this nation was founded on the idea that the people should rule.
​
That’s why it is so important that Americans be informed about their government. They are partakers in it. In fact, they control it...


...Unfortunately, we are not very well-informed.
Mr. Stepman cites a study by the Woodrow Wilson National Fellowship Foundation which concludes that only one out of every three Americans (actually 36%) can pass a standard test for becoming a citizen of their own country.  That's probably not too shocking as we see what is emphasized in schools and colleges these days, but considering that only 60% is considered passing, it really is shameful.

I feel confident that my fourth graders could do a reasonable job on the test, and I have now worked up my own version to use in the classroom.  I know they could effectively answer some of the questions better than the results of the Wilson survey indicate for the general public.
  • Seventy-two percent of respondents either incorrectly identified or were unsure of which states were part of the 13 original states;
  • Only 24 percent could correctly identify one thing Benjamin Franklin was famous for, with 37 percent believing he invented the lightbulb;
  • Only 24 percent knew the correct answer as to why the colonists fought the British;
  • Twelve percent incorrectly thought WWII General Dwight Eisenhower led troops in the Civil War; 6 percent thought he was a Vietnam War general; and
  • While most knew the cause of the Cold War, 2 percent said climate change.
Picture
Stepman concludes that all of this means we must make fundamental changes in how we approach education in the United States.  On this, he is probably correct, but perhaps he would concede that he doesn't have all the answers.  I would suggest that the changes need to be include the area of state/national standards, teacher education, classroom focus.

While it is important for states to set reasonable standards for public school classrooms, those standards are often misdirected to the wrong students or the wrong levels.  More likely, the standards do not emphasize our nation's history as much as they could.  With a little elbow grease, we could include more at all levels with extensive focus at particular points along the grade levels.  Since states have emphasized literacy and mathematics (with a little science peppered in) on standardized tests, history and social studies is easily relegated to the closet.  I've even heard of principals (not ours of course) who have demanded that their teachers do not teach social studies, but to use every possible minute to emphasize reading comprehension.  Undoubtedly, reading comprehension is crucial, but for decades, I have voiced my concern that purpose for reading is also important.  History is interesting to my students; there are days when they go home telling their parents everything I've taught them about it.  Likewise, I almost always help them make connections between history and their own lives.  How have we gotten to this point in current events and standards of living?  They understand more by studying history and connecting the dots. When states do not recognize the importance of learning from history and civics, they run the risk of an ignorant citizenry!

Secondly, there are too many teachers who can only skim the surface of our history, forcing in a few boring facts on certain holidays and calling it good.  Some of those time-worn facts are not even facts:  Columbus discovered America, George Washington cut down his dad's cherry tree, etc.  The reason might be that in our own teacher-prep and collegiate careers, history was absolutely not emphasized.  In other words, while colleges of education have focused their attention on so-called STEM, literacy, math, and general methods for teaching, they have removed any emphasis from history (unless, I suppose, one happens to be a history major).  At some point we have to talk about more than just reading comprehension of history texts to tick a box.  At some point, we must offer teachers more content training!  Until then, some kids coming through elementary school will only know that Johnny Appleseed planted apple seeds (Even then, they won't know that he was actually planting apples for the purpose of fermentation.).

Finally, many teachers will put history on the back burner because they didn't sign up to teach history (Actually, they did, but who's looking?).  For many teachers at the elementary level, they dreamed of becoming teachers for many reasons outside of our current topic.  For some reason, many fail to consider that they have the responsibility of fostering a responsible and reasonable, informed citizenry.  They may not think much about teaching the branches of government and their checks and balances.  They may not think about the importance of teaching voters to base their votes on which candidate has the best yard signs or slogans.  Unfortunately, the emphasis in some classrooms can be more on the cuteness of the bulletin board, the silliest dress up days, or the latest magical software subscription than on the future of society.

Stepman puts it this way:

We don’t want to become trapped by the past, but we do want to learn from it in order to avoid repeating past mistakes and build a better future. As citizens, knowledge of the past and of civics is crucial. Lacking such knowledge is unhealthy for a free country, and even dangerous, given how bad political life can become.
0 Comments

The War that Made America:  the First World War

7/6/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
I have referred to the French and Indian War as the first world war a few times since last summer's Teacher Institute at Mount Vernon, but I had not fully understood the depth of that statement until reading more about the motivations and methods employed by the players at the time.  In Fred Anderson's volume about the war, The War that Made America, he discusses more of the narrative.  Anderson begins putting the pieces together, making the case that the French and Indian War was truly a global event.

But first, since I will participate in Fort Ticonderoga's Teacher Institute this summer, I was interested in reading about the building of the fort by Frenchmen in an effort to block the enemy from effectively using Lake George to access Lake Champlain going north, as well as establishing a command center for sending troops south to New England.
...Johnson's men were too shocked and demoralized by the battle to pursue the enemy, who regrouped at Crown Point and then set out to build a new fort at the foot of Lake George, on the promontory of Ticonderoga.  For Carillon, as they called it, would become both the main obstacle on the Lake Champlain invasion route and a base for raids against the New England frontier.
It helps to understand how the war was not simply local history.  The players were European and North American, but they did not just send troops across the Atlantic to fight with each other.  There were other strategies at play and other interests in mind.

Great Britain had the greatest naval force on earth.  As an island nation, Britain understood the need for well-armed ships to defend itself.  With no air threat at the time, there was no other route to take in attacking the country.  That said, as disciplined as their army was, it was not a defensive force for the most part.  France understood all of this and more, and planned its fights with England carefully.  In North America, it would be important to keep the British from becoming strong on the water.
France, meanwhile, was prepared to fight a war that, its leaders believed, would consist mainly of actions against Britain's man source of commercial strength, its empire.  There was no real intention to use the troops stationed in Brittany and Normandy to invade England, only to tie down Royal Navy and army units in coastal defense, making it safer and easier to attach British overseas possessions in North America and the Caribbean, and perhaps to seize the British East India Company's trading factories at Calcutta and Madras.  Chances seemed excellent that a weakened Britain would beg for peace in three or at most four years' time.
At the same time, a controlled skirmish was not in the cards.  With a strategy of having fronts located in Europe and in Caribbean waters, events spiraled out of control, and this war would become a bloodbath involving more than just two neighbors spatting over the property line.
The explosion of a general war in Europe destroyed France's plans for a limited Anglo-French confrontation beyond the seas.  All the preparation that Versailles had done could do nothing to control the direction of events.  As 1756 ended and 1757 began, the gathering momentum of a general war in Europe preoccupied government leaders in France and Britain alike, while the war in North America proceeded according to a violent logic of its own.
0 Comments

Reading about Champlain, the French and Indian War, & WWI

7/5/2019

0 Comments

 
With an upcoming week-long educational residency in Ticonderoga, New York, I feel an obligation to prepare myself by reading.  The following make up the strange set of books I read before the trip (Interested in reading more?  Click to go to my page about the Fort Ticonderoga Teacher Institute.).
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
This year's theme of study at the fort is “World Wars: Historical Comparison of the French & Indian War and World War I”.  That's right.  We're going to learn about two wars, and not one of them is the Revolutionary one.  Not only that, but I will be trekking through completely new territory for me - the Adirondacks of Vermont and New York.  Let me just say that books featuring the French and Indian War or World War I don't take up much space in our local library, and books about the fort and its surrounding geography are pretty much non-existent.

One book I picked up after the teacher institute at George Washington's Mount Vernon, last summer, is Young Washington. This publication tells of the earliest part of Washington's life - the years preceding the Revolution.  I had no idea I would be so interested in the French and Indian War prior to the Mount Vernon venture and reading this volume.  Young Washington is a page-turning masterpiece, telling of Washington's lineage, his teen years, and his foray into military life.  Here is a book that is not afraid to criticize the future father of a nation for his ignorance, his vanity, and his impatience.  Here, too, is a book that demonstrates Washington's growth and learning process. His is a story of learning from mistakes and his growth into a maturity that fell into place at just the right time for the birth of a new, free nation.

The second book is a book for kids.  As I read this Ranger in Time book, I understood Long Road to Freedom to be a runaway slave story set in the pre-Civil War era, and I did not expect a connection to the Ticonderoga area.  Then, wouldn't you know it, the runaway slaves skirted up the coast of Lake Champlain and crossed it on a ferry with the help of the Underground Railroad.  The book helped me understand some of the geography that I will see on my excursion, this summer.  As I don't have extra days to spend in the area, I will not be able to visit the North Star Underground Railroad Museum in the area, but it has been a bonus to read a bit about the abolitionist activity in the area a hundred years after the French and British fought and fifty years before the first world war.

The Dear America volume, When Christmas Comes Again, was a slow starter, but it helped me understand how women infiltrated the military ranks during the war.  This book is supposed to be about the young ladies who acted as translators and telephone operators in France, but ended up being more about a young lady's yearning to meet the love of her life.  Perhaps in reading this story I will be able to better understand Stephen Pell's vision of the war (Stephen Pell is the French WWI medic who is responsible for restoring Fort Ticonderoga.).  Perhaps Pell met one of these hello girls girls at some point in his experience, though I doubt his experience would be as eventless as Simone's.

Our public library does a pretty good job of stocking books about many topics:  World War I is not one of those topics.  About the only thing I could find was a book about the decade before the war, so I checked it out.  Theodore Roosevelt is a short biography about his years in the presidency, and gave me just enough information to help me understand the where the United States was, economically and politically especially, when the years leading up to the war.  Roosevelt, being the first president to step off of U.S. soil during his term, was clearly a player on the world stage, and wanted everyone to understand that our nation could hold its own in military action.
0 Comments

Music Appreciation:  America the Beautiful

7/4/2019

0 Comments

 
Here's a bonus lyric video just for the holiday.

​Stay safe as you celebrate our nation's independence.

And let's keep this straight:


The date is July 4.

​The holiday is Independence Day.
0 Comments

Book:  Halfway Normal

7/3/2019

0 Comments

 
The best part of this book is the part where I closed the cover and didn't have to read it any more.  I know I should be promoting reading, but with the last two books I've read from Missouri's 2020 Mark Twain list have been terribly disappointing.  I've never been more disappointed in Missouri's school librarians than I am in their inclusion of this book.  Surely there is more quality literature available than this.
Picture
From the author's website:
Norah Levy has just completed two years of treatment for leukemia and is ready to go back to the “real world” of middle school. She knows it’ll be tricky–but like the Greek mythological characters she read about while she was sick, Norah’s up for any challenge.
​
But seventh grade turns out to be trickier than she thought. Norah’s classmates don’t know what to make of her. Her best friend, Harper, tries to be there for her, but she doesn’t get it, really—and is hanging out with a new group of girls. Norah’s other good friend, Silas, is avoiding her. What’s that about, anyway?

When Norah is placed with the eighth graders for math and science she meets Griffin, a cute boy who encourages her love of Greek mythology and art. And Norah decides not to tell him her secret—that she was “that girl” who had cancer. But when something happens to make secret-keeping impossible, Norah must figure out a way to share her cancer story.

But how do you explain something to others that you can’t explain to yourself? Can Norah take her cue from her favorite Greek myth? And then, once she finds the words, can she move forward with a whole new ‘normal’?
My problem with this book is that it should have a disclaimer for parents.  The synopsis from the author might seem to be a description of wholesome story, but there is just too much hidden in Dee's delivery:  the main character's consistent worry that she will not develop as quickly as her female peers (stated much more bluntly in the book), talk of herself coming of age (again, I'm not stating this as directly as the author), a quick mention of a same-gender relationship that has nothing to do with the story, the cavalier way in which marriage infidelity is handled, the placing of manna in the category of mythology, and one descriptive word that uses a profanity not normally found in a children's book all tell me more about the author's political and religious beliefs than I needed to know.

I appreciated that Norah, the main character, was frustrated with the showy little ways that are connected with cancer awareness, and I thought the author captured her inner frustrations well, but all of the other issues in the book overshadow the good writing.  In short, I would not be happy if my daughter brought this book home to read only to find out it leans so far in one direction that the main idea of the story is lost in the personal ideologies of the author.  These things should be communicated more directly on the cover and not hidden within the lines of text.
0 Comments

The First World War:  Into Africa

7/2/2019

0 Comments

 
Picture
When I picture the two named World Wars, I do not immediately conjure images of Africa, so when reading the next section in Hew Strachan's book, The First World War, I found some of the African portions of the war to be interesting.

​By this time, the war is truly world-encompassing.  Nowhere is that more obvious than on the African continent.
In 1914 the entire continent of Africa with the exception of Liberia and Ethiopia was under the rule of European powers, principally Britain, France, Belgium and Germany.  Of the other colonial powers in Africa, Spain, Italy and Portugal, and Spain remained neutral throughout the war, and Portugal entered the conflict in 1916 principally in order to secure international support for its shaky authority in Africa.
Sadly, when Africa is involved, things can never be discussed without race becoming an issue.  We may never get far enough from the issue of race to say it exists solely in the past.  Just consider the thought processes of some white leaders during World War I:
To many whites it seemed self-evident that the use of colonial troops to topple other European powers could only be self-destructive in the long term.  War would rekindle the very warrior traditions that colonialism had been designed to extirpate, and ultimately the black trained to use a rifle against a white enemy might turn his weapon on his own white ruler.
While the second world war is the one we think about concerning a superior race, those ideas did not begin in the 1940s.
Smuts was determined that his campaign was going to prove the invincibility of the white man.  The South-West African campaign had been an affair of whites only.  When the 1915 mixed-race Africans had offered to rise in revolt in support of the South Africans, the later rejected their cooperation for racial reasons.
Still, we will not reduce the Great War to a squabble over racism.  Racism is certainly part of the history, but just as the American Civil War was not solely about slavery, the first world war was not fought over African equality.  It is not as simple as saying whites didn't like blacks, and they fought to suppress them.  The fact remains that some whites feared people with darker skin.  Indeed there may have been stereotypes that spread due to the fact that cannibalism did exist among limited groups in Africa.  Stories about such could have made whites afraid of being dominated by people who practiced this kind of barbarism.  Those types of fear - and continuing ideas that blacks were thought to be generally inferior because of a Noahic curse - could turn races against each other.

​Strachan wraps up this section with this:
In the eighteenth century Britain and France had fought each other in India and America for the control of continents.  This was not why war came to Africa in 1914.  The powers did not fight to take territory.  Indeed, the most obvious immediate effects were to loosen the holds of empires.  Most whites in the colonies feared that the sight of Europeans fighting each other would promote rebellion and resistance.  Those fears could only grow as local administrators joined up, and as local forces turned from their policing function to that of confronting an external enemy.  But such fears proved exaggerated.

Why put myself through the reading of 340 difficult pages?  It is all a part of my preparation for the Teacher Institute at Fort Ticonderoga in July.  For more anticipation and reflection on the week-long experience, go to my Fort Ticonderoga page.
0 Comments
<<Previous
Forward>>

    Anthem

    The Hoggatteer Revolution
    is
    an extensive,
    award-winning, 
    inimitable,
    digital platform
    for Encouraging
    ​and Developing
    ​the Arts, Sciences, and honest Christianity

    in the beautiful, friendly

    LAND OF THE FREE
    AND THE HOME
    ​OF THE BRAVE
    This site is described as
    "a fantastic site... chockablock full of interesting ideas,
    hilarious ane
    cdotes,
    and useful resources."
    Picture
    Picture
    ...to like, bookmark, pin,
    ​tweet, and share

    about the site...
    and check in regularly
    for new material,
    ​posted
    often before 
    ​DAWN'S EARLY LIGHT!

    Picture

    History in Residence

    Elementary Schools:
    ​Bring Mr. Hoggatt
    into your classroom
    for a week
    of engaging
    ​
    and rigorous

    ​history programming
    ​with your students.

    ​LEARN MORE
    Picture

    Intercom

    GigSalad Member Since 2022
    Book Mr. Hoggatt Securely
    ​for Your Event
    ​at GigSalad.com.

    Email Mr. Hoggatt
    Picture

    Trophy Case

    Picture
    Preacher, starting 2025
    Picture
    Project TRAILS, starting 2025
    Picture
    Student Teacher Supervisor, since 2022
    Picture
    Master Teacher, since 2021
    Picture
    Recruited Lincoln Presidential Foundation Curriculum Writer, 2022
    Picture
    Retiree, 32 years serving Joplin and Oklahoma City Schools, 2022
    Picture
    Selected Participant for 2020-2022
    Picture
    Selected Honoree/Celebrant, 2022
    Picture
    Outstanding Achievement, 2022
    Picture
    Classroom Grant, 2018-2022
    Picture
    2021 Missouri History Teacher of the Year and National History Teacher of the Year Nominee
    Picture
    Recognized in Joplin Globe, February 2021
    Picture
    Teacher Institute Participant, 2019
    Picture
    Summer Residency Participant, 2018
    Picture
    "The Bus Stops Here" Grant, November 2018
    Picture
    Summer Residency, 2018
    Picture
    Recognized 2017
    Since 2017
    Picture
    MSTA Media Award, KOAM-TV's "Manners Matter", Featuring Our Class, May 2017
    Picture
    Third Place, 2016 Film Festival
    Picture
    Recognized 2016
    Picture
    Slide Certified, 2012
    Picture
    2009 Outstanding Class Website
    Picture
    2005 Nominee
    Picture
    2005 Joplin Teacher of the Year and Missouri Teacher of the Year nominee
    Picture
    2004 Recipient
    Picture
    2002 Excellent Education Program
    Picture
    2001 Nominee
    Picture
    1996 Outstanding Classroom Video
    Picture
    Grant Recipient, 1993

    Picture

    Fireside Chats

    Picture
    Choose Your Platform:
    Anchor
    ​Apple Podcasts (iTunes)
    Breaker
    Google Podcasts
    ​
    Overcast
    Pocket Casts
    RadioPublic
    Spotify
    Stitcher
    Picture

    Archives

    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012

    Picture

    Checks & Balances

    Links to external sites
    on the internet are for convenience only.

    No endorsement or approval of any content, products, or services is intended.

    Opinions on sites are not necessarily shared
    by Mr. Hoggatt
    (In fact, sometimes
    Mr. Hoggatt doesn't agree with anyone.)
    Picture
Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.

Picture